The WIAA’s decision last week to go to 5 divisions for it’s girls and boys state basketball tournaments is certainly drawing some controversy. I’ve ready many blogs on this topic. It seems fans are overwhelmingly against this. Coaches seem equally split between “we don’t need this” or “I’m fine with it either way” or “this helps us out.” I guess it depends on how the new divisions affect them individually. With that said I’ve taken a closer look at how this affects Coulee Region teams. I’ve broken them down into two categories, “better off” and “worse off” with the idea of how it affects their chances of making it to state.
BOYS TEAMS BETTER OFF:
All 3 city teams–Central and Logan no longer have to go through a Madison area school to get to state. That’s been the kiss of death for them for about two decades. Central’s sectional matches them up with teams from the Eau Claire, Wausau, Appleton and Oshkosh areas. A really good Central ballclub will match up better with teams from those areas. Logan drops down to division 2. So not only do they not have to worry about Madison area schools but they are in a sectional that features 4 MVC rivals and a bunch of teams to the north and east that are similar in enrollment. A really good Logan team could find an easier path to state with this group. Aquinas stays in division 3 where they will be a favorite to make it to state out of their sectional most years. None of the teams in their sectional is a perennial power or has the history the Blugolds have.
Holmen, Tomah—Same reasons as Central and Logan. Both of these schools move from division 1 to division 2. No more trips to Madison area for playoffs and for early round exits. Holmen is back in division 2 which is where they were when they last made it to state in 2004.
G-E-T– OK, I know, they’re in the same sectional as Aquinas. But G-E-T moves from division 2 to division 3. Coach Wagner has some good teams on the horizon and they might have a team talented enough in the coming years to get past a team like Aquinas. If they do, like I mentioned earlier, the rest of the schools in this sectional don’t scare you.
Blair-Taylor, Westby–Blair-Taylor made a memorable run to state last year in division 3. But let’s face it, facing Racine St. Catherine’s in the semifinals was the “poster child” game for the rural vs. urban controversy. Even so, B-T gave them a good game. So imagine how much better they will fare next season and down the road knowing there are all public schools and towns of similar size in their sectional. Not only that, there will be no Aquinas, Racine St. Catherine’s or Whitefish Bay Dominican waiting for them in the pre-tournament or at the state tournament. The private schools in division 4 are not perennial powers. After going 0-6 at state, I think B-T head coach Randy Storlie will finally bring home a gold or silver ball soon. Many of the same arguments can be used for Westby. It seems Bob Constalie always has competitive teams and his ballclubs will fare favorably in this sectional as well.
Any local team in division 5–Looking at the division 5 sectional from our area, there are no powerhouse programs. So if one of our area teams has a really good team, chances are better they can make a run at state. Of course, Randolph moved to divison 5 as well (in another sectional). So winning a state title will still be a daunting taske for anybody in division 5 from our area.
BOYS TEAMS WORSE OFF:
Onalaska–The past two seasons you could pretty much count on the Hilltoppers facing Northwestern in the Sectional final. Well, Northwestern moves down to division 3 but Onalaska stayed in division 2 where they will face much better competition to get to state in their sectional. In fact, Antigo made it to state last year in division one (althought they lose their best player). Onalaska still has the talent to make it through this area’s sectional. It will just be tougher.
Black River Falls– The Tigers went from a manageable division 2 sectional to a tougher division 3 sectionals that features Aquinas and an up and coming G-E-T.
GIRLS TEAMS BETTER OFF:
All 3 city teams–Basically, for the same reasons mentioned as the boys above. Central girls don’t have to play Madison area teams although the schools in the Eau Claire and Oshkosh area are tough as well. I think last year’s Logan team, even without Michelle Mueller, would’ve had a better chance of making it to state in the sectional they’re in now in division 2. With their young talent I think their road to state became easier. As for Aquinas, no Cuba City waiting for them at Sectionals. This is definetly better for the Blugold girls.
Holmen, Tomah—Same reasons as boys above. Holmen girls did not fare well in division one. They made it to state in division 2 in 2005.
Onalaska Luther, Westby– They move down to division 4. They were in the same sectional as Aquinas (and Cuba City for that matter). This new division 4 sectional gives Luther and Westby better shots at making it to state.
Independence–Now in division 5, they’re not in the same sectional as Barnevled any more, which typically has strong programs.
GIRLS TEAMS WORSE OFF:
There are no area girls teams that are significantly worse off in my opinion. I think a team like West Salem, which moved down to division 3, did not gain much, if anything at all.
———–
I’ve been calling games at the boys and girls state tournament for the past 15 years. Even though the five division format is being met with a lot of skepticism state-wide, I still think those are the best two weeks of the year. I can’t wait to see how it works out, for better or worse. What are your thoughts?
Posted under Uncategorized
This post was written by semerich on June 29, 2010
3 Comments